The insight from research into regulation, to the effect that that knowledge is important for legislative governance processes, point to the way the legislature and authorities find themselves faced increasingly with the question as to how situations of not-knowing do affect legal decisions. The PhD project took up this enquiry using the example of youth media protection and sets out concretely the leeway for assessment and prognosis the various actors have, verifiable legally only to a certain extent, at the levels of the legislature, of the responsible authorities and of the institutions of voluntary self-regulation – in the face of uncertainty.
The PhD project examined the forms of knowledge deficits concerning legal decisions in the German Law for Protection of Minors in Media [Jugendmedienschutzrecht] for broadcast and telemedia, as it is written in the Interstate Treaty on the Protection of Minors in the Media [Jugendmedienschutz—Staatsvertrag]. The analysis focused on determinants of legislative decisions, which means the general and specific constitutional requirements for decisions in cases of uncertainty. In the following course, the work lookd at the single decisions made on downstream levels: on the one hand, there are different causes depending on the kind of decision-making or its level, i.e. the level of the legislator, the approved authorities and within the scope of established bodies of voluntary self-regulation in the system of regulating self-regulation. On the other hand, an important category of legal decisions under uncertainty as a field emerged from the judicial review, namely the possible scopes of assessment and judgement and the relevant control density in the judicial review. This field is being controversially discussed/became the subject of a controversial debate in literature, especially since it is explicitly written in the Law for Protection of Minors in Media that the self-controlling bodies (under private law) have “scopes for judgement evaluation”. The combination of the following factors can deliver deeper results than it is possible in any other areas of law:
In the first part of this work, the subject and causes of uncertainty sheds light on within the scope of legal decisions – and how the law can and has to react to it. Subsequently, in the second part analyses what determinants of specific categories for decisions in the area of youth media protection emerge from the constitutional requirements concerning the protection of minors. The third part gives an overview of the sub-constitutional framework of youth media protection in Germany. Selected types of decisions under uncertainty and the guidelines and standards/criteria, which were presented in the first two parts for various situations of decision-making, will be examined in the fourth and last part. By doing so, a typology of decisions under uncertainty in child protection against harmful media was developed, so that relevant programmes for decision-making as well as their guidelines can be considered in a more differentiated way.
This project was finished in 2018 and published by Nomos:
Dreyer, S. (2018): Entscheidungen unter Ungewissheit im Jugendmedienschutz. Untersuchung der spielraumprägenden Faktoren gesetzgeberischer und behördlicher Entscheidungen mit Wissensdefiziten [Decisions under Uncertainty in the Protection of Minors in the Media. Analysis of the Factors Influencing the Scope of Legislative and Official Decisions with Knowledge Deficits]. Baden-Baden: Nomos, 431 p., paperback, ISBN 978-3-8487-5393-2, 114,- EUR, Publishing Information
RP3 - Knowledge for the Media Society
The institute will provide scientific support for the media conference in the context of Germany's 2020 EU Council Presidency and is analysing in advance the requirements of a modern European information order.
How do children and adolescents in Europe use the Internet; which risks do they encounter and how do they handle them? The project EU Kids Online has been dealing with these questions since 2006.
Children and young people use media to position themselves within their social groups and contexts. Together with colleagues of the FAU Erlangen-Nuremberg, we examine in a longitudinal study what role their media repertoire and their communicative practices play and how these change over time.
In the digital sphere, children and young people establish relationships towards real life, fictitious and artificial media figures. This entails risks. The project examines to what extent the German regulation on the protection of minors from harmful media contents is still suitable to protect a fr...
Is user-generated content on private communication platforms protected by freedom of expression? In her PhD project, Amélie Heldt focuses on the effect of the fundamental right on freedom of expression on the Internet.
In the Jugend Medien Schutz-Report (Youth Media Protection Report), Kira Thiel and Dr. Stephan Dreyer give an overview of sticker use practices by children and young people in messenger services and address the associated risks. To the article (fee required) Abstract Happy teacups, cute dog...
The Law on the Protection of Minors from Harmful Media is too old and calls for modernisation. In the current issue of the journal Kinder- und Jugendschutz in Wissenschaft und Praxis [Protection of Minors in Science and Practice], Dr. Stephan Dreyer gives an overview of the planned changes, their po...
Dreyer, S.; Schulz, W. (2020): Written Statement on the Draft of the Youth Protection Act at the Expert Discussion "Protection of Minors in the Media" of the CDU/CSU and SPD Parliamentary Groups. 25.05.2020.
In this contribution, Dr. Claudia Lampert and Marcel Rechlitz introduce the approach of communicative figurations as an analytical framework for researching transformed socialisation processes. The article has been published in Bewegungen: Beiträge zum 26. Kongress der Deutschen Gesellschaft f&...
Dr. Stephan Dreyer will talk about "Mythos Jugendschutzmaschinen: Reichweite, Grenzen und Fragen automatisierter Inhaltsbewertungen durch Software [Myth of Machines for the Protection of Minors: Scope, Boundaries and Questions of Automated Content Assessments Using Software" at the event "KJM...